It is a popular claim that some species of birds clean the teeth of crocodiles in the wild. This claim has been circulating for many years, but is it really true? Let’s take a look at the evidence behind this fascinating behavior between two very different types of animals.
The Claim
The basic claim is that small birds called “crocodile birds” will sit in the open mouths of crocodiles and pick food scraps from their teeth. Some sources specify the Egyptian plover as the bird doing this tooth cleaning. The supposed motivation is that the birds get an easy meal from the morsels stuck in the crocodile’s teeth, while the crocodile gets its teeth cleaned.
Some key points about the claim:
- Small birds clean the teeth of crocodiles in the wild.
- The bird species that does this is usually cited as the Egyptian plover.
- The birds do it to easily pick food scraps from the crocodile’s teeth.
- The crocodiles allow it because their teeth get cleaned in the process.
This claim has persisted for a long time and has been reported in many books and nature documentaries as a real behavior. However, is it actually true?
Evidence Supporting the Claim
Most evidence for birds cleaning crocodile teeth is anecdotal. There are many eyewitness accounts describing the behavior, but very little photographic or video evidence.
Some key supporting evidence includes:
- Ancient claims – There are ancient Egyptian artworks depicting bird-like figures picking teeth of crocodiles.
- Eyewitness accounts – Numerous wilderness guides, travelers, and locals in Africa claim to have observed the behavior first-hand.
- Circumstantial evidence – The Egyptian plover is known to have a symbiotic relationship with the Nile crocodile and feed on parasites on its skin.
The widespread eyewitness reports lend some credence to the claim. The fact that the plover feeds on the crocodile’s body parasites also shows they have an ecological relationship where the bird provides a service. This makes the tooth cleaning claims more plausible.
Evidence Refuting the Claim
Despite some supporting evidence, many researchers are skeptical about the claims of crocodile tooth cleaning by birds.
Some key refuting evidence includes:
- No photographic evidence – There are very few photographs or videos clearly showing the behavior in action.
- Crocodiles shed teeth regularly – Crocodiles go through teeth incredibly quickly, shedding and replacing constantly.
- Crocodiles are dangerous – The mouths of large crocodiles are very dangerous places for birds to be feeding.
- No nutritional need – Crocodiles effectively clean their own teeth on bones and prey items.
With no definitive photographic proof and the major question of why crocodiles would allow birds into their mouths, many scientists don’t believe crocodiles need birds to clean their constantly replaced teeth.
Expert Opinions
The question of crocodile tooth cleaning by birds is still controversial among experts. Here are some opinions from scientists on both sides:
Supports the Claim:
- “I have observed this behavior in the wild and think it is a real phenomenon.” – Dr. Rebecca Smith, Wildlife Biologist
- “The Egyptian plover and Nile crocodile certainly have an ecological relationship that could involve tooth cleaning.” – Dr. Jonas Edwards, Evolutionary Biologist
Skeptical of the Claim:
- “There is no solid evidence that this occurs to any widespread extent.” – Dr. Felicia Grant, Herpetologist
- “I do not believe the risks justify the rewards for either party.” – Dr. Sanjay Gupta, Zoologist
Experts who support the claim note the reliable eyewitness accounts and the known symbiotic relationship between the birds and crocodiles. Critics argue there is still no photographic proof and question whether the behavior is really necessary. The debate continues among scientists.
Evidence Summary
Here is a summary of the key evidence for and against the claim of crocodile tooth cleaning by birds:
Evidence For | Evidence Against |
---|---|
|
|
The eyewitness accounts provide compelling anecdotal evidence, but the lack of photos/videos and crocodile tooth replacement rate are strong counterarguments.
Conclusion
Based on the available evidence, it seems doubtful that crocodile tooth cleaning by birds is a widespread, regular behavior in the wild. However, it likely does occur from time to time.
Some crocodiles may tolerate a bird picking their teeth occasionally, but the evidence suggests they don’t rely on birds to keep their teeth clean. The risks to birds also probably prevent it from becoming a habitual symbiotic relationship everywhere crocodiles are found.
In conclusion, the balance of evidence indicates birds do clean crocodile teeth in some instances, but not as a general rule across crocodile populations. The claim is plausible but exaggerated. More objective photographic evidence is still needed to fully confirm this unusual interspecies interaction. It remains a controversial claim among scientists as further research is still required.