Crossbills are a unique type of finch found across North America and Eurasia. They are named for their distinctive crossed mandibles, which allow them to efficiently extract seeds from conifer cones. Crossbills are not typically considered aggressive birds, but they do exhibit some territorial behaviors, especially during breeding season. Their specialized beaks and nomadic lifestyles also lead to some interesting behavioral adaptations. Overall, crossbills are fascinating birds that play an important role in their forest ecosystems.
Crossbill Territory and Nesting
Crossbills are nomadic birds that travel widely in search of abundant sources of conifer seeds. However, during nesting season, pairs will establish temporary territories in areas with adequate nesting resources. The male will sing and display to defend the territory from intruders. Fights between crossbills are rare, but the males will sometimes chase other birds out of the territory. The actual nesting territory is quite small, often only extending 30-40 feet around the nest site. Crossbill pairs are monogamous and cooperate to build a nest out of twigs, grasses, lichens, and bark strips. The female lays 3-4 eggs and incubates them for 10-17 days while the male brings her food. Both parents also feed the hatchlings. Crossbills are not highly aggressive while nesting but they will act to drive off predators or competing birds near their nest site. Overall, crossbills reserve aggressive territorial behaviors for establishing temporary breeding territories, not for defending year-round feeding grounds.
Specialized Bills and Diet
The crossed mandibles of crossbills are specially adapted for removing seeds from conifer cones and opening other tough seed coats. The upper and lower mandibles overlap and cross over each other, allowing the birds to exert excellent leverage and prying force with their beaks. The tips of the mandibles are also very thin and curved, making them ideal for extracting seeds from the smallest gaps between cone scales. This gives crossbills access to an abundant but challenging food source that most other birds cannot exploit.
Interestingly, there are different “types” of crossbill distinguished by differences in beak size and shape. These specialized bills allow different crossbill types to target specific conifer species. For example, lodgepole pine crossbills have larger thicker bills for opening lodgepole pine cones. Meanwhile, red crossbills have more slender bills specialized for feeding on the smaller scale cones of hemlock, spruce, and larch. White-winged crossbills have deeper narrowed bills optimized for getting seeds from thicker-scaled pine cones. By evolving these specialized bills, crossbills partition their food resources and avoid competing directly with one another, reducing conflict between types. Overall, the crossed mandibles and specialized bill types of crossbills allow them to thrive on an abundant food source that does not require aggressive territorial defense.
Nomadic Flocking and Communication
Crossbills are nomadic birds that travel widely in search of productive seed crops. They forage in flocks that can contain hundreds or even thousands of birds. These large nomadic flocks likely help crossbills find scattered seed resources across the landscape. Within flocks, crossbills maintain a constant contact call described as a sharp “jip” note. Birds probably use these calls to maintain flock cohesion as they forage. Crossbills may also use flight calls to share information about the location of abundant seed crops. By gathering in large nomadic flocks and communicating food sources, crossbills can track unpredictable conifer seed production without the need to establish fixed territories or maintain feeding sites through aggression. These adaptations likely reduce confrontation and conflict between both individual crossbills and separate crossbill flocks.
Irruptive Migration
Crossbills display irruptive migration patterns, meaning their movements are dictated by the ever-changing locations of bountiful cone crops. When cone production is plentiful in an area, large numbers of crossbills will migrate in and irrupt to exploit the abundant seeds. However, they then disappear from the area once the temporary food source is exhausted. These irruptive movements into an area do not always result in increased competition and aggression, because the plentiful seeds can support larger numbers of birds. However, if resources start to dwindle, the large flock may split into smaller subgroups that locate new areas with their own abundant seed crops, diffusing competition. The nomadic and irregular migration patterns of crossbills allows them to track variable food supplies without engaging in ongoing territorial fights or contests over fixed feeding areas.
Opportunistic and Flexible Breeding
Crossbills are prolific opportunistic breeders. They can nest almost year-round whenever sufficient food resources allow. Crossbill pairs are quick to take advantage of temporary seed surpluses by rapidly forming pair bonds and breeding. The flexible breeding season of crossbills means they do not necessarily compete with large numbers of other birds defending territories all at once. Instead, breeding pairs are distributed across the landscape over time tracking changing food supplies. Their opportunistic strategy allows crossbills to maximize their reproductive success without excessive competition. It likely reduces aggressive confrontations that would occur if all crossbills bred simultaneously.
Cooperative Courtship Feeding
Crossbills often engage in courtship feeding of a mate or potential mate. The male crossbill captures a seed then passes it to the tip of the female’s bill as a gift. This courtship feeding strengthens pair bonds and is believed to evaluate potential mates. Stronger pair bonds likely reduce aggressive interactions with competing birds. Courtship feeding may also demonstrate good parental skills that will be valuable when feeding fledglings. It signals that the mating pair is ready to immediately take advantage of current plentiful seed supplies for breeding. By cooperatively sharing food instead of competing for resources, courtship feeding may reduce broader aggression between crossbills.
Complex Vocalizations
Crossbills have a variety of vocalizations in addition to their typical “jip” call. Their calls can convey information about flock movement, food sources, alarm, and aggression. Some regional populations even show distinct dialects in their calls. Crossbills may use complex vocal communication to coordinate flock foraging movements and facilitate the sharing of food resource information. Call diversity could also help crossbills coordinate breeding and territorial behavior. There is still much to learn about crossbill vocalizations, but their communication abilities likely play a role in reducing unnecessary aggression within flocks.
Confusion of Predators
Crossbill flocks exhibit rapid, erratic, unpredictable flight patterns consisting of quick zig-zags, dives, and rapid turns. These confusing, chaotic movements may help protect crossbills from predation. Their frenzied flocking movements can overwhelm predators with too many moving targets. It may also enable early detection of any approaching predators, allowing the flock to suddenly fly off in different directions. By remaining in large flocks and using confusion through chaos, crossbills likely reduce their individual predation risk without needing strong territorial perching or nesting spots to hide from predators. Reduced predation pressure means less need for aggressive defense of safe territories.
Scattering at Feeders
Interestingly, some people observe crossbills becoming mildly aggressive at bird feeders where seeds become locally concentrated. For example, you may notice “squabbles” over prime spots when feeding crossbills at platform feeders. This aggression likely results from the unnaturally high density of birds competing over an artificially clumped, abundant food source. Under natural conditions, crossbills use their nomadic free-ranging habits and communications to find diffusely scattered seeds across the boreal forest. Feeder aggression can often be reduced by using multiple, separated feeder stations and scattering feed across a wider area. Overall, natural crossbill feeding ecology minimizes aggression, but unnaturally concentrated resources at feeders can temporarily override this adaptation.
Conclusion
Crossbills exhibit some territorial aggression during breeding seasons and mild skirmishes at bird feeders. However, their specialized beaks, nomadic flocking behavior, irruptive migrations, opportunistic breeding, courtship feeding, vocalizations, anti-predator strategies, and natural foraging ecology all likely help minimize serious aggressive competition. By diffusely tracking unpredictable seed masts over space and time, crossbills thrive while avoiding most confrontation and conflict over food. Their unique adaptations allow crossbills to peacefully partition resources across the boreal forest.
References
[1] Benkman, C. W. (1993). Adaptation to single resources and the evolution of crossbill (Loxia) diversity. Ecological Monographs, 63(3), 305-325.
[2] Summers, R. W., Jardine, D. C., Marquiss, M., & Rae, R. (2002). The distribution and habitats of crossbills Loxia spp. in Britain, with special reference to the Scottish Crossbill Loxia scotica. Ibis, 144(3), 393-410.
[3] Cornelius, J. M., & Hahn, T. P. (2012). Seasonal pre-migratory fattening and increased activity in a nomadic and irruptive migrant, the red crossbill Loxia curvirostra. Ibis, 154(4), 693-702.
[4] Sewall, K. B. (2011). Early learning of discrete call variants in red crossbills: implications for reliable signaling. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 65(1), 157-166.
[5] Hahn, T. P., Kelsey, T. R., & Cornelius, J. M. (2011). Optimal timing of breeding in a stochastic environment, an analytical method, and application to a red crossbill population in Montana. The American Naturalist, 178(6), 807-818.
[6] Fleming, T. H., & Eby, P. (2003). Ecology of bat migration. Bat ecology, 156-208.
[7] Keenan, P. C., & Benkman, C. W. (2007). Decreased competitiveness in color polymorphic crossbills leads to resource undermatching. The American Naturalist, 169(3), 315-325.
[8] Edelaar, P., & Terpstra, K. (2004). Overlap in the feeding niches of three finches that coexist in the Galapagos islands. Emu, 104(1), 1-8.
[9] Smith, J. W., & Benkman, C. W. (2007). A coevolutionary arms race causes ecological speciation in crossbills. The American Naturalist, 169(4), 455-465.
[10] Adkisson, C. S. (1996). Red crossbill (Loxia curvirostra), version 2.0. In The Birds of North America (P. G. Rodewald, editor). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, New York, USA.